Supreme Court expands presidential power to fire independent agency heads
September 15, 2025
Systemic Escalation
Founders' Principles Violated
Guardrails Violated
Separation of powers and constitutional balance between branches violated.
Independence of regulatory agencies from political interference undermined.
Constitutional checks and balances between branches of government bypassed.
Established judicial precedent and legal precedent protecting institutional independence challenged.
Trigger
Supreme Court decision in Trump v. Slaughter expanded presidential power to remove heads of independent agencies without cause, potentially overturning Humphrey's Executor precedent that protected agency independence.
Action Taken
Supreme Court ruled on September 15, 2025 that the president has broader authority to remove heads of independent agencies (FTC, NLRB, etc.) without cause, challenging the 1935 Humphrey's Executor precedent. Decision potentially undermines independence of regulatory agencies and increases presidential control over independent oversight.
In His Own Words
"The president must have full control over executive functions."
"Independent agencies cannot be completely insulated from presidential oversight."
What's Wrong
Supreme Court decision expands executive power at expense of independent agency autonomy. Challenges long-standing precedent protecting agency independence from political interference. Undermines separation of powers and checks on executive authority.
Impact
Institutional: Undermines independence of regulatory agencies and oversight bodies. Legal: Overturns or challenges long-standing precedent protecting agency autonomy. Operational: Increases presidential control over independent agencies, potentially enabling political interference. Constitutional: Shifts balance of power toward executive branch.
Related Entries
Sources & Full Details
Primary Sources
Background
Humphrey's Executor v. United States (1935) established that heads of independent agencies could only be removed 'for cause,' protecting agency independence. Trump v. Slaughter (September 2025) expanded presidential removal authority, potentially allowing removal without cause. This decision affects FTC, NLRB, and other independent regulatory agencies.
Why Level 4?
Systemic escalation: Supreme Court decision expands executive power over independent agencies. Multiple guardrails bypassed: separation of powers, independent agency autonomy, established precedent. Permanent institutional change affecting balance of power.